Impacts Witness / Extreme Weather / Slow onset disasters
Meteorologists are citing concerns over changes in the track of Monsoon weather systems across the country. The trend has become more and more visible in the last 4-5 years, with the 2022 season being the latest one. In fact, recent Pakistan floods have also been attributed to this change.
India records excess Pre-Monsoon Season 2023, gives heatwave a miss The pre-Monsoon season for the country ended with surplus rainfall to the tune of 12% of the Long Average Period (LPA). All three months (March-May) have recorded excess rainfall countrywide.
Data Source: IMD (Rainfall figures in mm)
While the majority rainfall contribution came from Central India, East and Northeast India was the only pocket to record deficit rainfall. Out of 36 sub-divisions of the country, 17 were large excess during the season, four saw excess rains, and 7 recorded normal rains. Meanwhile, six sub-divisions received deficient rains, while two were large deficient.
Excess rainfall led to below-normal maximum Temperatures observed over Northwest India, giving a miss to heatwave season this year. West Bengal was the only pocket to see a major heatwave spell from April 11-19. Following are the number of heatwave days observed across the country during the season.
Month-wise performance:
May: The month ended with surplus rainfall for the country to the tune of 10% of its LPA of 61.4 mm. Out of the 36 subdivisions of the country, 24 recorded normal to large excess rainfall, while others were deficient to large deficient.
According to the statistics, Northwest India recorded 67.3 mm of rain during May, the third highest since 1901. Before this, 1987 had recorded 95 mm, followed by 2021 with 68.2 mm during the month. Meanwhile, East & Northeast India received 111.3 mm of rainfall, the third lowest since 1901. Prior lowest rainfall years for the regions are 1907 with 108.1 mm of rain and 2012 with 109.6 mm.
Temperature Profile: With the above-normal rainfall, India recorded close to normal maximum and minimum average temperatures. The maximum temperature for the month was recorded at 35.03°C and the minimum temperature was 23.92°C, with an anomaly of -0.14°C and -0.40°C, respectively. The maximum temperature was above normal by 4.4°C mainly over most parts of North India and East & Northeast India and coastal parts of India.
Northwest India: Not only the rainfall, but the region also recorded the eighth-lowest average maximum temperature of 33.53°C, which was lower by 2.06°C since 1901. Similarly, the average minimum temperature was the seventh lowest at 20.09°C with an anomaly of -1.37°C during the same period. The mean temperature was also the eighth lowest at 26.81°C with an anomaly of -1.71°C since 1901.
Central India: The average minimum temperature for May was the sixth lowest at 25.20°C with an anomaly of -0.74°C since 1901.
East & Northeast India: In the absence of rains, the average maximum temperature was the eighth highest at 34.33 ºC with an anomaly of 1.30 ºC since 1901.
Heat Wave: Subdued heat wave conditions were observed during May, following similar trends in March and April 2023. Heatwave spells were observed for a span of 2-3 days over a few pockets of the country. The first week (1-8 May) and last week (24-31 May) did not observe heatwave across the country.
Weather Systems: May saw a series of back-to-back eight WDs, which is quite unusual during this time of the year. Passage of these systems led to widespread pre-Monsoon rains and thunderstorms, along with lighting, hail storm, and squally winds, especially over Northwest and Central India. These weather activities kept the maximum temperature below average over the regions.
April: The month also saw above-normal countrywide rainfall by 5% of its LPA. Central India recorded 30 mm of rain, which was the fourth highest since 1901. Meanwhile, East & Northeast India received 63.8 mm of rainfall which was the fifth lowest during the same period.
Out of the 36 subdivisions of the country, 26 recorded normal to large excess rainfall, while others were deficient to large deficient.
Weather systems: April witnessed five active Western disturbances (one in the first week of the month and four in the second half of the month). There was also the persistence of trough/wind discontinuity running from central to Peninsular India. Both weather systems together led to large-scale thunderstorm activities and rainfall, accompanied by lightning and gusty winds over India along with hail storms. Due to such extensive rain/thunderstorm activities and cloudy conditions over most parts of India, large parts of India experienced lower-than-normal day maximum temperatures during these periods.
The absence of weather systems along with south-westerly or southerly winds and moisture convergence from the north Bay of Bengal to the region was the reason behind the subdued rainfall and thunderstorm activities over northeast India in April.
Temperature Profile: The average maximum, average minimum and mean temperature for the country as a whole during April 2023 are 34.19°C, 22.08°C and 28.14°C respectively, against the normal of 33.94°C, 22.15°C and 28.04°C based on the period 1981-2010. Thus, the average maximum temperature is above normal by 0.26°C while the average minimum temperature and mean temperature are normal by -0.07°C and 0.10°C respectively for the country as a whole. The average Maximum temperature was above normal by 4.5°C mainly over most parts of East & Northeast India and coastal parts of South Peninsular India.
Peninsular India: Over South Peninsular India during April, the average maximum temperature is the seventh highest (35.03°C with an anomaly of 0.77°C).
Heat Wave: During April 2023, there was no heat wave during 1-10 April and 21-30 April due to the occurrence of thunderstorms and rainfall activities, especially over Northwest and West-Central India. During 12-20 April, heat wave condition was observed over West Bengal for 9 days, Bihar – 7 days, Odisha – 5 days, and Coastal Andhra Pradesh-4 days during the period.
Punjab, Haryana, Chandigarh, Delhi, and Uttar Pradesh saw heatwave conditions for 1-3 days, while Konkan & Goa and Jharkhand just saw one day of Heat Wave activity.
March: March was the best-performing month of the pre-Monsoon season 2023, with 26% surplus countrywide rainfall of its LPA. Out of the 36 subdivisions of the country, 29 recorded normal to large excess rainfall, while others were deficient to large deficient.
According to the statistics, Peninsular India recorded 32.1 mm during the month, the seventh highest since 1901. Similarly, Central India also saw the 11th highest rainfall during the same time period with 23.9 mm of rainfall.
Weather systems: After the hottest February in 123 years on account of the absence of Western Disturbances, March 2023 saw seven WDs formed moving across north and central India. Due to back-to-back WDs, an east-west trough was formed from Rajasthan to eastern India. Another north-south trough was seen running from south Peninsular India to east-central India, which is a semi-permanent feature during the pre-Monsoon season. The country saw widespread rainfall, especially from March 14-22.
Temperature Profile: The average maximum temperature for the country was recorded at 31.37°C, which was above normal by 0.13°C against the normal average of 31.24°C. Similarly, average minimum and mean temperatures were recorded above normal at 19.46 ºC and 25.41 ºC respectively, against the normal of 18.87°C and 25.06°C. However, these above-normal temperatures were the result of hot weather in the first half of the month. Maximum temperatures were below normal departure since March 17 because of thunderstorm activity over many parts of the country.
Heat Wave: No heatwave was recorded during the month.
Impacts Witness / Slow onset disasters
In the solar potential regional analysis, future projections predict a shift in the frequency of solar radiation in the negative direction, implying that solar energy production will decrease in the immediate future.
Adaptation Witness
World Water Day was observed across the globe this week. CarbonCopy takes a look at the sustainability of one of the India’s flagship water supply programmes, which is in a race against time to provide 100% water supply to rural India
The latest IPCC report on Mitigation of Climate Change provides an exhaustive list of solutions across the energy, buildings, transport, land and industrial sectors which show that it is possible to cut emissions quickly and cheaply. It is clear that the next few years are very critical for countries that are accelerating mitigation measures. Unless we accelerate mitigation across all sectors and regions, 1.5 will remain beyond reach.
Economic instruments include carbon pricing instruments, subsidies, etc. These pricing instruments now cover about 20% of global emissions, much of that is through emissions trading mechanisms, which are dominated by Europe and China. The new Chinese English is really making something very substantial, as well as carbon taxes. These have definitely been shown to be effective but they also work in complementary ways with regulations. The report talks about how you have carbon pricing instruments, but you also have regulations. These regulations are very widespread and actively used in sectoral policies such as building codes, energy efficiency standards including both performance standards as well as things like India’s bad performance trade scheme, which is a tradable regulatory mechanism with flexible instruments. There are hybrid things and these flexibility mechanisms definitely help the cost-effectiveness of those regulatory instruments. Coming back to the pricing instruments, an interesting finding of the report is that these carbon pricing instruments have incentivized low-cost emissions reductions, which is what they are designed for, in a sense, the lowest cost reductions but on their own without complementary instruments and at current carbon prices have not really been able to incentivize higher cost mitigation options. So for the scale of transition that you either need a much higher carbon price or you need complementary mechanisms to induce innovation such as we’ve seen in renewable energy feed-in tariffs and subsidies for certain technologies and so on. So again, it comes back to the point that there is no single silver bullet. We have to design these packages carefully and design them given a particular context. There’s been a lot of learning about how you design these market instruments better. Subsidies have also been used quite effectively, particularly for innovation.
IPCC’s Working Group III report sends out a clear message that the global average investment is required to achieve 1.5°C or 2°C by 2030, the current projections show that the flow of finance is 3 to 6 times less than required on a global average basis at present. The finance shortage is across the globe but the gap is relatively higher in developing regions like Asia, Africa and Latin America. It is a substantial problem to mobilise necessary finance. However, we should read this issue in conjunction with enabling conditions that include finance, technology and innovation, institutions and policy, all have to work together. We cannot mobilise finance individually as it would not work and vice-versa. This needs to include a transition that is just. Hence, the language of development pathways is important because it talks about shifting the whole approach to lining up all these things in ways that enable transitions that are both low carbon, sustainable and just.
When we look at finance, we have to make a choice on what we are investing in it. This report provides evidence of what those investments can be. For eg: When building a city or settlement, you will plan your roads, infrastructure and service access. That will determine the nature of the investment. SPM Fig 6 shows that different sectors can have granular technology applications and infrastructure design to provide access to people so that their increasing demand for well-being doesn’t conflict with reducing emissions but in fact creates more jobs and opportunities. We need to look at the economy-wide impact of financial investment. Finance mobilisation will depend on how you are making a choice on where you want to invest. Chapter 5 gives examples of how public transit systems can be more secure, and comfortable and also reduce the carbon footprint for every individual. We talk of finance as a constraint, but it would really be useful if we look into how we shift our developmental choices, how we involve people in the whole process and then how we can make the financial arrangements. It is not always that we need a lot of finance. We have shown that there are many options where the cost of mitigation is very low as compared to the damages the impact could have had.
You cannot talk about Net Zero alone; you have to look at what is happening in the short run and to the extent that Net Zero is a useful way of mobilising sub-national actors. There have been lots of initiatives at the city level, lots of transnational initiatives and all of these things contribute to the formulation of Net Zero targets. It’s important that they be credible and don’t have leakage effects where reducing emissions in one place displaces emissions to another place. The key message is that to stabilize the climate, you need to reach Net Zero but the immediate short-term issue is what are we going to do in 2030. One has to have both conversations, particularly for countries like India who are on the upslope of emissions which translates to a question not of reducing emissions, but of avoiding emissions.
One thing is very clear that for Net Zero, the Carbon Dioxide Removal (CDR) technology will have a very important role to play. On the other side, we must see what we can do to reduce the burden on the supply and look into the demand so that more known, less-risky and off the shelf options can be implemented. Chapter five is about off the shelf and development oriented solutions, which will advance development, create employment, increase investment, but in a cleaner way. CDR is also talking about a cleaner way, but it is for the first time IPCC has come up with so much scientific information on CDR. So there can be biological methods, which include reforestation, afforestation, which we say very clearly. But then there are also others and all these have different layers of cost implication. If we are talking about the solutions, which reduce the cost burden and increase the benefit, then we need to really compare among the different options available and countries have to make a choice. Countries also must decide how much they want to scale up CDR. If you think you can be oblivious to emissions and capture all by planting trees, then you may not have a human settlement and land full of trees. So there are several challenges in large scale deployment of CDR methods. Or what we can do is reduce the emissions to begin with, so we do not have to remove it from the atmosphere and that’s why Chapter Five is very important because it is about how you can reduce emissions by involving people. So it is for countries to decide if we need a cleaner city with less air pollution, electrification, active mobility, a walkable city or do we go for carbon dioxide removal and fossil fuel use. The report has made a very comprehensive assessment of all the different CDR methods, and so how to combine, monitor, evaluate and govern them has become a major scientific evidence from this report, which can be very useful for decision makers.
India’s GDP per capita is already 16% lower than it would have been without human-caused warming since 1991, according to a study cited by the IPCC report [Ch 16, p.22]. India is the country that is economically harmed the most by climate change, with every tonne of carbon dioxide emitted globally costing the country around $86, according to a separate study cited by the report